The Hidden Truth Behind People-Pleasing: It's Not Just About Saying "Yes

As a psychotherapist with years of experience working with clients—and let’s not forget, my own personal relationships—I’ve come to develop a theory about people-pleasers that might surprise you. When we think of a “typical” people-pleaser, we envision someone who is constantly saying “yes,” bending over backward to make everyone else happy, and running themselves ragged in the process. But here’s the kicker: it’s not always about saying yes—sometimes, it’s just about an inability to say no.

Let’s unpack that.

Are You a People-Pleaser? Let's Dive In

From my work with clients, one thing is crystal clear: people-pleasers often fall into a recurring pattern. They say “yes” to something they have no business agreeing to—whether it’s helping a friend move or attending an event they don’t want to go to—and then when the time comes to follow through, they disappear. Suddenly, they’re avoiding the person they promised and hoping the whole thing will just... disappear.

Why? Because the fear of disappointing the other person is so overwhelming that they can’t bring themselves to face the reality of it. They’re terrified of the confrontation and, on a deeper level, the potential rejection. But here’s the catch—disappointment is inevitable.

Let me paint a picture for you: Imagine I’m moving and ask a friend to help. They say “yes,” but deep down, they’re already regretting it. Come moving day, they bail. Now I’m left scrambling for help at the last minute. I’m disappointed, sure, but it’s worse than that—because now I have no backup plan. My expectations were set based on their “yes,” and their failure to follow through means I'm left in a bind.

In this case, both parties end up disappointed. And for the people-pleaser? They’ve just doubled the emotional cost because they can’t even confront the situation. It’s a lose-lose.

Is This Really People-Pleasing, or Just a Fear of Saying No?

So, here’s a thought: is it really people-pleasing, or is it more about an inability to say “no”? When we dig into it, the root cause often boils down to a deep fear of conflict or confrontation. People-pleasers fear the uncomfortable feelings that arise when they have to set boundaries and stand up for their own needs. They’d rather avoid the conflict, even if it means agreeing to something they can't deliver on.

The Art of Saying "No"

One of the most valuable techniques I teach my clients who struggle with this pattern is learning to pause before giving an answer. If someone asks you for a favor, don’t give a knee-jerk “yes.” Instead, try something like, “Let me get back to you on that—I might have another commitment,” or, “Can I let you know tomorrow? I need to check my schedule.”

The key here is follow-through. This isn’t about finding clever ways to avoid commitments—it’s about giving yourself space to make a thoughtful decision. You have to get back to the person within the timeframe you promised. Integrity is crucial here. If you say you’ll follow up, follow up.

The Silent Vacuum of Avoidance

Where things tend to get messy is in relationships where there’s little-to-no confrontation. In these dynamics, needs go unmet, and the people-pleaser’s avoidance becomes the elephant in the room. But neither party addresses it—because neither one wants to rock the boat. Over time, this creates a toxic pattern where the people-pleaser keeps disappointing others and, even worse, themselves. It’s a vicious cycle that keeps relationships in a stagnant, unproductive space.

A Case Study of the "People-Pleaser" in Action

Let’s break this down with a little case study, shall we? Meet Sally Sue. Sally agreed to help her friend Mary Jo clean out her garage next weekend. Then, when the weekend rolls around, Sally goes completely off the grid. Mary Jo tries to reach her, but Sally goes silent. Days pass. No response. Weeks pass. Still no word. When Sally finally resurfaces, she acts like nothing ever happened.

Here’s the problem: Mary Jo is left to stew in her disappointment, but Sally’s avoidance creates an even bigger issue. It’s not just the broken promise; it’s the fact that Sally never even acknowledges it. This is classic “gaslighting” behavior, where the wronged person is made to feel like they’re crazy for being upset. In this case, Mary Jo may not address the issue directly, because Sally’s indifference pushes her into a position where she feels like she shouldn’t even bring it up. So, instead of calling out Sally, she just silently adjusts her expectations and moves on.

Sound familiar?

The Bottom Line: We Can Do Better

Here’s the deal: if you’re caught in this pattern of people-pleasing, it’s time to do better. It’s time to stop fearing confrontation and start having those difficult conversations. Growth and change don’t happen in the comfort zone—they happen when we face adversity, when we challenge ourselves to be honest and set boundaries.

If you find yourself struggling with people-pleasing or the inability to say no, don’t suffer in silence. Let’s work through it together. The people who truly care about you? They can handle the truth. So let’s break the cycle of avoidance and build more authentic, honest relationships. Because in the end, you’ll thank yourself for it.

#therelationshipprescriber #peoplepleasing #meetyourneeds #yespeople #confrontation